She left her hesitations behind with her home-made woolens.

Miss Pettigrew Lives for a Day by Winifred Watson

Back in 1938 when Winifred Watson first submitted Miss Pettigrew to her publisher they didn’t want to accept it. Watson replied “You are wrong, Miss Pettigrew is a winner.” She was quite right, because Miss Pettigrew is most definitely a winner.


Written in 1938 Miss Pettigrew is an utterly delightful and absurdly affectionate fairy-tale. It tells of how the mousey and over-looked Miss Pettigrew through a clerical mishap at her employment agency meets nightclub entertainer Delysia LaFosse and over the course of a single day has her life utterly transformed.

Miss Pettigrew is:

a middle-aged, rather angular lady, of medium height, thin through lack of good food, with a timid, defeated expression and terror quite discernible in her eyes, if any one cared to look.

That “if any one cared to look” there is devastating. Miss Pettigrew is a desperate woman. Her money’s run out, her string of governess jobs have been a sequence of disasters and if she can’t find a new position within the day she’ll be homeless. Her clothes are threadbare and she expects nothing but rejection when she goes for one last job interview.

When she knocks on Delysia LaFosse’s door what she finds isn’t what she expects at all. Delysia is beautiful, glamorous, rather fast. There’s no evidence of a child (because Miss Pettigrew has been sent to the wrong job) and Delysia has no idea why she’s there but Delysia’s life is full of random happenstance so the appearance of a dowdy middle-aged woman isn’t particularly surprising to her.


Before Miss Pettigrew can explain her presence the dashing young Phil emerges from the bedroom. Miss Pettigrew is shocked, but when Delysia asks for help to get Phil out without hurting his feelings she somehow manages the task and from there the day is set. Shortly after the doorbell rings again and in walks Nick, nightclub manager and by appearance matinée idol. He’s fantastically jealous and if he learns Phil’s been there it’s all up for Delysia. Suddenly Miss Pettigrew is needed. She’s never been that before.

What follows is a dizzying array of callers and escapades. Phil and Nick aren’t the only men in Delysia’s life and while Delysia is charming an ability to cover her tracks isn’t among her talents. Soon Delysia has adopted Miss Pettigrew, Guinevere, as a dependable friend in her hour of need. Miss Pettigrew tries to muster up the courage to say she’s there for a job but instead finds herself sucked into a world of glamour and just plain fun that her parents long warned her against and yet which doesn’t seem so bad when she finally sees it in the flesh.

Miss Pettigrew sat savouring to the full a blissful sense of adventure, of wrongdoing: a dashing feeling of being a little fast: a worldly sense of being in the fashion: a wicked feeling of guilty ecstasy. She enjoyed it. She enjoyed it very much.

There are cigars left behind by Phil to explain to the magnetically caddish Nick, the smoothing of Delysia’s friend Miss Dubarry’s boyfriend troubles to attend to, a cocktail party to attend, a first visit to a nightclub… As the day goes on Miss Pettigrew finds herself something else she’s never been before: accepted.


Until this day Miss Pettigrew had always prized being a lady above all else. It hasn’t got her much, only “polite, excluding courtesies” from gentlemen and her current poverty. Still, it’s how she was raised:

Powder, thundered her father, the curate, the road to damnation. Lipstick, whispered her mother, the first step on the downward path. Rouge, fulminated her father, the harlot’s enticement. Eyebrow pencil, breathed her mother, no lady … !

It explain a lot that her father thundered and fulminated while her mother whispered and breathed. What hope poor Miss Pettigrew? No wonder she made her forties without ever having been kissed.

Delysia though gives her confidence, asking for help and advice and sharing without second thought her clothes and life. Miss Dubarry owns a leading beauty salon and gives Miss Pettigrew a transformative makeover (something often promised in real life, but which more usually seems to result only in the purchase of another moisturiser and a remarkably expensive eyeshadow).

It’s nonsense, of course, but it’s beautiful nonsense. I was reminded slightly of The Grossmiths’ The Diary of a Nobody which like Miss Pettigrew is a supremely compassionate novel. Nobody here is truly wicked, even Nick who’s the closest to a villain the book has is just vain and self-centred rather than actually being bad.

The book does contain a few of the less pleasant attitudes of its time. Miss Pettigrew at one point criticises Phil as having “a little Jew in him” and suggests “when it comes to marriage it’s safer to stick to your own nationality”. Happily, these elements come up on only one or two pages out of the entire 234-page novel and I think one can make some allowances for when it was written.

Miss Pettigrew is an old-fashioned champagne glass of a novel. It’s deceptively light, effervescent and packs a surprising punch. It’s always pretty obvious what’s going to happen, and yet I wanted to see it happen all the same because Watson had me caring about all of them. Will Delysia find the right man? Will Miss Dubarry be reconciled with her Tony? Will Miss Pettigrew’s new friends stick by her when they learn why she really turned up? You don’t need to read the book to know how those questions will be answered, but as with any good romantic comedy the trick is in how they’re answered. It’s a book for when you’re feeling a bit down and need a lift, or if you’re emerging from something terribly dark or serious and need a breath of heady air. It’s lovely, and that’s not a word I get to use of many of the books I tend to read.

I’ll end by noting that this was my first Persephone Books title and I was hugely impressed by the sheer quality of the book. It’s nicely bound, sits well in the hand, the paper’s high quality and the spine doesn’t crack when you hold the book open. It’s peppered with period illustrations from the original text which are quite adorable and it even comes with its own bookmark. Extraordinary.

Other reviews

Lots, most of which I’ve lost the links to. Here however is Jacqui’s of JacquiWine’sJournal, here‘s Ali’s of Heavenali and here‘s Simon Savidge’s of SavidgeReading. As ever please feel free to link to others in the comments.



Filed under Comic fiction, Watson, Winifred

19 responses to “She left her hesitations behind with her home-made woolens.

  1. I saw this (through reviews and from websites) but I’ve hesitated thinking it was perhaps too saccharine. A matter of mood perhaps. Plus I gave up on the film…

  2. To be fair it is pretty sacharine. I mentioned romantic comedies for good reason, that’s what it is. Given you don’t tend to like romance I do wonder if you’d take to this one. You definitely need to pick your mood, if you wanted something incisive this wouldn’t answer at all.

  3. Lovely! Miss Pettigrew is an old-fashioned champagne glass of a novel – yes, and I see it as one of those traditional saucer shaped glasses as opposed to a flute. Pure indulgence.

    So glad you enjoyed it, Max, and many thanks for the link. I think you’re right in saying that it’s about how the questions will be answered rather than the outcome itself (which is never really in doubt). Persephone have done a great job with the production of this novel, they’ve added so much value over and above the words on the page.

  4. Definitely, that’s what I meant by old-fashioned, I just couldn’t think quite how to capture it without a picture. Pure indulgence indeed.

    I was looking at Persephone’s website and it seems this was a big, and I think company-transforming, hit for them. Well deserved if so.

  5. Ah, of course! I’d like to try a few more of the books from the Persephone catalogue as I can’t recall seeing a poor review of any of their titles. Jane Hervey’s Vain Shadow is on my classics list, one to pick up at some point.

  6. Miss Pettigrew was my first Persephone book too. Years ago I now have 80+. I have read this twice. I still adore it.

  7. I’d have to fit it in after let’s say… Derek Raymond.

  8. Glad Miss Pettigrew won you over, Max. Yes, it’s pure fantasy and escapism, but gloriously done and when that’s what you want it’s spot on! Persephone Books are absolutely lovely and surprisingly varied if you have a look at their stocklist. I’m very fond of “The Hopkins Manuscript” by R.C. Sherriff – Wellsian sci fi and surprisingly prescient in some ways.

  9. And since nobody’s mentioned it, the book made a charming little film, too, back in 2008. With Frances McDormand, Amy Adams, and Ciaran Hinds —

  10. I think I might have to leave this for happier times – not sure I would react well to it at present! The only Persephone I’ve read is their collection of Irene Nemirovsky short stories but I do love the format.

  11. Sounds like good fun, if you fit it to the right mood Max.

    I’m not sure I own any of Persephone’s titles – I do see them fairly often. They’ve a pretty eclectic list, looking at their site.

  12. Sorry for the slow replies all.

    Vain Shadow’s not one I know. I’ll look it up.

    Heavenali, I’m not surprised it bears rereading. It reminds me of Wodehouse a bit. It’s not that you don’t know roughly what’ll happen anyway, it’s the sheer fun with which it gets there.

    Guy, after Derek Raymond I fear this would seem a hollow and joyless mockery, but then what wouldn’t? You do remind me that I still have some of his standalone stuff to read. I should pick up A State of Denmark, it seems topical presently.

    Kaggsy, I did take a look and you’re quite right. I’ll check out the Sherriff.

    Mark, that’s some cast. Thanks, I’ll take a look.

    Grant, happier times or when needing a lift. Probably not for genuinely dark times though, it’s a little too light to bear that kind of weight so would be unkind to it.

    Ian, it’s definitely about the mood, but then many books are. I’ve had a fairly busy July at work with quite a few hours getting put in, which is reflected in a sudden spate of relatively light books.

  13. This is a book I don’t think I’d usually be drawn to but from your review, it sounds wonderful and great escapism. I love the way you describe it as an old-fashioned champagne glass of a novel. Added to the to-read list!

  14. “Miss Pettigrew is an old-fashioned champagne glass of a novel.” you got me with this sentence.

    I remember Jacqui’s review and now yours confirms I’ll probably like it. I enjoy these “soft” books from time to time.

    The paper edition seems really good, too bad I’ll have to stick with the kindle version.

  15. Great escapism is right Gemma. I do think you’d enjoy it.

    Emma, I’m glad that sentence seems to have resonated with people. I do think it’s fair. I think you’d like it, but you do need to be in the mood for something light and silly and escapist (as Gemma says). It’s nonsense, but lovely nonsense so you need to be up for that or it could seem a bit slight.

  16. Pingback: 2016 end of year roundup | Pechorin's Journal

  17. Pingback: Miss Pettigrew Lives for a Day by Winifred Watson | Book Around The Corner

  18. Pingback: Miss Pettigrew Lives for a Day – findingtimetowrite

  19. Pingback: Miss Pettigrew Lives for a Day, by Winifred Watson | ANZ LitLovers LitBlog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s